Sunday, June 24, 2012

Reasons to Protect Test Cricket?

Cricinfo seems to be be featuring at least one article per week on the future of test cricket and/or the ODI. It's all getting a bit tiresome; the columnists appear to be putting together the same old cliches, while offering no fresh insights of any kind. Harsha Bhogle's latest article is a case in point.

The most recent piece is from one of my favourite contemporary Indian writers, Mukul Kesavan. In this article, he does a reasonable job of establishing the context in which things have changed rapidly over the last half-decade or so. His diagnosis does include one important observation:

Pundits, cricket administrators and news channels were all part of the IPL's booming economy, so there was no stable perch from which the interests of Test cricket could be independently articulated. All the people who might have been expected to make the case for the long game - distinguished ex-players, concerned administrators, veteran commentators - were so busy feeding at the IPL's trough that it was easier to duck the problem by saying all was well.

Unfortunately, the article still feels like a wasted opportunity because he doesn't (adequately) make the case for test cricket's existence, or suggest ways in which it might be effectively sustained. He touches upon a possible reason for preserving the format in the last paragraph:

It's useful to think of Test cricket as a tropical rain forest that nurtures a diversity of things bred out of the monoculture of limited-overs cricket. Diversity escapes the balance sheets of money men, but it is, as ecologists have taught us, invaluable.

This has me thinking. Do we have any compelling reasons for protecting test cricket? Off the top of my head:

The Need for Balance. Currently, people are drawn to the shorter forms, especially T-20 because it is still regulated to an extent, it isn't shoved down one's throat for 12 months of the year. Remember the format isn't even a decade old: my feeling is the Indian audience would tire of it if it wasn't largely confined to the IPL for two months of the year. You need to provide alternatives for the remaining months, even if the revenues they generate aren't comparable with those provided by the shortest form.

Preserving Skills.  Guys like Pollard and Afridi aside, it is mostly players who have excelled in the longer form of the game who remain the biggest draw, whatever the format. Players still value success in tests, whatever their motivations may be - David Warner and Kevin Pietersen to name two. The basic skills nurtured from playing test cricket are still a measure of quality for many of us. Point being, in isolation the shorter formats would breed one type of player alone, and quickly become become unwatchable. Making room for all sorts is one of cricket's biggest strengths.

Maintain a Nursery for Feeding the Other Forms. Related to the point above. If the shorter forms of the game are indeed its breadwinners, you need a steady stream of quality players to sustain them. So the administrators could view test cricket in a different light - as a breeding ground for potential limited-overs stars.

Clutching at straws, maybe, but this is all I'm able to come up with. Are there any other possible reasons, or is its continued existence simply not justified any more?  

Saturday, June 23, 2012

Freddie versus Athers

One of my pet hates is the tendency of people, when confronted with a difference of opinion, to attack the person making the argument rather than the argument itself. This usually takes the form of "Have you ever been in this profession yourself?" or "Have you ever been in so-and-so's shoes? What makes you qualified to comment, then?" A cricketing example can be seen in the way certain fans are quick to insist that Sachin Tendulkar is beyond even the slightest criticism from former players whose cricketing achievements aren't on par with his.

So, it was interesting to see Andrew Flintoff employing this line of attack against Michael Atherton recently. That the two don't get along is not really surprising; Atherton is the intense, poslished Cambridge graduate, while Flintoff's image is more working-class hero. Atherton the journalist can be vitriolic at times, and we are supposed to  believe this is Freddie's way of sticking up for his former teammate, Alistair Cook. Only, if Freddie felt so strongly about Atherton's comments about Cook at the time, why didn't he say so then? 

Let's assume, for the sake of argument, that Atherton's cricketing credentials do matter if he is to talk about current players. Flintoff himself has been pretty well-placed to judge Atherton's accomplishments: his international debut was in the Trent Bridge test of 1998, which is simply remembered as the Atherton vs Donald match. He was also in the playing XI in another test against the South Africans which featured an Atherton epic, when the side were being tossed around by Donald and co. once more. 

He was on the fringes of the national side in 2000, when Atherton played out of his skin to help England to their first series win against the West Indies since god-knows-when. If that isn't enough, he was on that tour to Pakistan, where England's series win was set up by Athers' painstakingly compiled 125. Alistair Cook is a fine batsman alright, but ten times better than Athers, really? Unless his memory has failed him badly, the only explanation for Freddie's outburst is the one he himself offers, unwittingly: "there's no love lost here". 

Freddie has a right to his opinions and, given the nature of modern cricket coverage, it's a safe bet we'll be subjected to them regularly. Based on this line of reasoning, however, they'll be pretty hard to take seriously.

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

The Contracts List: A Few Talking Points

The list of nationally-contracted players for 2012-13 has provided a fair bit to talk about, actually. With Buchanan and Kim Littlejohn calling the shots, perhaps that was always going to be the case. Still it's hard not to think "Is this the best NZ can do?" when you look at the list.

To be fair to the selection committee, NZ have played precious little cricket since the end of the 2011 World Cup - 7 tests, 9 ODIs and 7 T20s (for comparison's sake, England, who generally don't play a lot of limited-overs cricket, have played 21 ODIs and 8 T20s to go with 15 tests in that period). So they haven't had a lot to base the contracts list on, really.

The list of 20 is as follows:
Trent Boult, Doug Bracewell, Dean Brownlie, Andrew Ellis, Daniel Flynn, James Franklin, Martin Guptill, Chris Martin, Brendon McCullum, Nathan McCullum, Kyle Mills, Tarun Nethula, Rob Nicol, Jacob Oram, Tim Southee, Ross Taylor, Kruger van Wyk, Daniel Vettori, BJ Watling, Kane Williamson

According to the criteria our friends Littlejohn and Robinhood have formulated, tests are supposed to get twice as much weightage as the other forms when it comes to selection. But the list only seems to reinforce the fact that tests are a distant third on the priority list, and NZC (perhaps justifiably) are hedging all their bets on the other two forms.

 How else can can you explain test specialists Mark Gillespie and Neil Wagner missing out while the Andrew Ellis, Tarun Nethula and Jacob Oram all make the cut on the basis of some half-decent performances against Zimbabwe? Of course, Wagner (who has been immense in the first-class competition) is yet to appear in a test but that never stopped others from getting contracted in the past. Gillespie, who made a superb comeback against South Africa and even bowled through pain, can feel pretty aggrieved at missing out while Tim Southee stays.

In addition, Franklin and Oram are lucky to be there considering they turn out very infrequently for NZ. I suppose the management sees them as important to NZ's chances for the World T20, though Franklin will probably feature more regularly later in the year.

Among those who dropped off the list: Andy McKay is a bit unfortunate to have slipped down the fast-bowling pecking order, Neil Broom even more so in that he never got a game to prove himself. And Jesse Ryder will be badly missed in the West Indies and in India, though one hopes he will be back sometime in the season.

To end on a positive note, it looks like Daniel Vettori has come out of retirement from the shorter forms and made himself available for the World T20 (though I wonder why everybody seems to be calling it a 'retirement' when it was an indefinite break). Given how dire NZ's limited-overs bowling was for much of last season, this will be a tremendous boost.

Saturday, June 16, 2012

Cricket Formats and Bookstores: A Thing or Two in Common

There exists a certain type of book-lover who is particular not just about what he reads, but also where he buys it from. It is mostly people of this ilk who are responsible for keeping the cult of the "friendly neighbourhood bookstore" going strong, even though the stores themselves are fast disappearing worldwide. Clearly, there is a certain romance associated with the local bookshop struggling to compete with the rise of a big chain counterpart; director Nora Ephron even made a well known romantic comedy on the theme.

One might wonder why a reader should prefer the smaller, minimalist store to the giant, glitzy establishment when the latter offers essentially the same product, at superior levels of convenience. The reader would probably offer a multitude of reasons: the sense of personal belonging which you simply don't get with the larger stores, the presence of knowledgeable owners or astute staff who wouldn't need a computer to tell you if a certain book were available, the likelihood of finding a rare title, or simply the stimulating environment.

This is a real-world parallel I hit upon while thinking about a seeming contradiction in cricket; the attitudes of die-hard test cricket fans, including myself, towards the various formats of the game. I may profess not to like it, but every year I end up watching a fair bit of the IPL anyway. I'm often asked why this is so, and a recent piece by my cousin (which appeared in Cricinfo's Inbox) went a long way towards providing an explanation; an IPL game, at its core, is still bat versus ball, and any cricket on television is better than none at all. My feelings about the T20 format, however, persist.

Perhaps it's not the league itself, but its knock-on effects - the proliferation of domestic T20 leagues, player availability, a badly compromised schedule - that leaves some of us cold. Whatever it may be, like many others I am the proverbial passenger on the train who simply has to catch a glimpse of the game being played outside, driven by that compulsive need to know what will happen next ball. Similar to this is how the reader who swears by the smaller store can still be found leafing through a book in the bigger one; the effect of a flame on a moth.

Every major Indian city now boasts an IPL franchise, but the test match still has more of a "community" feel to it than the domestic T20; when we were discussing the schedule for New Zealand's upcoming tour of India (tests at Hyderabad and Bangalore), a Hyderabad-based friend insisted he would rather get tickets for the Bangalore game because "nothing beats watching a test match in your hometown". Bangaloreans feel equally strongly about the quaint Premier Bookstore, which shut down three years ago, to the extent that a documentary film has been made on the owner.

Further similarities can be uncovered. The big-chain bookstore is usually found in a bustling shopping mall, and is seemingly incomplete without additions such as a DVD section and a coffee shop. By the same token, it is difficult to imagine a T20 game without floodlights, an excitable crowd, loud music, and cheerleaders. It sure hits home with the larger public, even if the purist finds this all a bit repulsive.

It is widely predicted that the older forms of cricket and bookselling will go the way of the dinosaur. But, like their book-loving counterparts, fans of the five-day format are a determined lot. Today, every reasonably absorbing test match, never mind the attendance figures, is a reason (or is it excuse?) for renewed optimism. The cause may be a losing one, but it is still worth fighting for.

Saturday, May 19, 2012

Exit Stage Wright

Well, it's happened. Earlier this month, John Wright decided he would not be renewing his coaching contract with New Zealand. As we feared, Wright goes out after the Windies tour in July, and NZ go two years backwards.

We can rant about John Buchanan as much as we like but the two of them were never really going to be able to work together. It's a bit unfair to blame the Australian, but I wish NZC had done a lot more to find an acceptable compromise between the two. One thing that has held NZ cricket back in the last five years is a complete lack of stability, and with the coaching role changing hands for the fourth time in four years, that looks set to continue.

The thing about 'Shake' Wright is he has little time for bullshit. He had taken up the job back in 2010 practically on public demand, and I suspect once he figured NZC were less than one-hundred percent behind him and his way of doing things, he decided he couldn't be arsed and was better off spending quality time at home after the contract expired. Rightly so, the guy does have a life outside cricket.

So we wait, for a new coach. Someone who must be able to forge a working relationship with Buchanan and accede to his selectorial decisions. That itself might rule out a number of good candidates.

It's times like this you curse the way your team is run and wonder when this shooting-yourself-in-the-foot business is going to stop.

Tuesday, April 3, 2012

Really, NZC?

One of cricket's oft-repeated truths is that New Zealand's resource pool is extremely shallow; when a few important men go missing, the replacements are usually never good enough.

I don't imagine I'm in a club of one in thinking that NZ's most valuable resource is a certain understated 57-year old. The good people running NZC, however, aren't exactly bending over backwards to retain his services. Strange.

Let's look back at the last three coaches of NZ before John Wright stepped in. Under John Bracewell, the Black Caps were a complete mess, with nonsense theories and experiments on players the order of the day. Brick-by-brick, Braces slowly succeeded in dismantling the house Stephen Fleming had built. His successor Andy Moles was little more than a passenger during a phase in which Dan Vettori did everything from captaining to driving the team-bus. As for Mark Greatbatch, five words he used to describe NZ's performance in Bangladesh tell you a bit about the impact he had.

Under Wright, NZ have stopped being truly wretched in both tests and ODIs, reached a World Cup semifinal in the subcontinent, clinically dealt with a minnow at home and away, won a test in Australia, and escaped a complete mauling from a ruthless South Africa. In the process, they've discovered a few good players (Doug Bracewell, Dean Brownlie) and resurrected a few careers. Doesn't sound too flash, but in the light of all that happened before, this man has turned things around.

But instead of assuring us that every possible effort will be made to keep him, we instead get this gem from John Buchanan: "In any professional sporting organisation you have strong people and sometimes you have positive tension. Sometimes that's a good thing, because you get [positive] outcomes". Months after losing the coaching services of Allan Donald, the men in charge seem happy to let things be.

Come on, NZC. This is the national side, not a bloody set of lab rats for Buchanan and Littlejohn to play Mad Scientist with.

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Day 5 at Wellington: Wrapping Up


For those wondering I had a drink after the game with Kane, he even had me sign his broken box! Haha! See, us quicks ain't that bad...
- Dale Steyn on Twitter

Phew. Thank you Williamson and Bracewell for batting out the draw. We shouldn't really have allowed ourselves to be in the position, but it's a nice little end to a torrid summer.

Before I start gushing about Kane Williamson's innings I think a lot needs to be said for Morne Morkel. He had thus far bowled superbly in the series without many wickets to show for it, and today was payday. You could argue that he set it up yesterday by cracking Ross Taylor's hand and thus eliminating him from the match, but today he was simply fearsome. After taking it upon himself to snuff out the top three, those yorkers to get rid of Brownlie and Vettori - delivered from sky-high - must have reminded old timers of Joel Garner in his prime. And there was the brilliant return catch off Kruger van Wyk on a day when chances were being spilled routinely. From the point of view of someone who's been overshadowed by Steyn and Philander, it's a shame the spell wasn't a matchwinning one in the end.

As for Williamson's innings, the word epic comes to mind. It had a sort of unforgettable, heroic, feel to it because (by remaining not-out) he lived to tell the tale. Despite all the mistakes, he showed tremendous temperament to bat through. Remember that Ross Taylor was absent, McCullum and Vettori were both dismissed without scoring, and he was batting in the knowledge that only an injured Gillespie and Chris Martin remained at the end.

It was all extremely chancy at the start, given he should have been out five times on the way to 20. First he shrugged it off by eventually unleashing a few strokes, and taking a few blows along the way. Then came the final session, where in the company of van Wyk and later Bracewell he turned into the immovable object NZ had needed all along against the relentless SA pace attack. It was noticeable through the series that improvement in South Africa's bowlers (to unbelievable levels) slowly brought out the best in KW. May this be the prelude to many more.

(The incident which ensured the innings will be part of cricketing folklore was when Dale Steyn struck Williamson in the box, and said 'I know that hurt but I'm not going to apologise'. As someone on the forum commented: "he put his testicles on the line for his country - literally".)

The series wouldn't have been complete without Graeme Smith firing a parting shot at NZ. The heady feeling of achieving the draw was marred when Smith claimed he didn't declare earlier because "NZ didn't deserve anything more". Sure, South Africa were much the better side and NZ weren't in with a shot, they're respectively 2nd and 8th in the world after all. But you first make a declaration aimed at fully eliminating the risk of losing - to a weak batting side missing its best batsman? - and then you attribute it to your judgement of what you feel the opposition 'deserves'? Real classy, Graeme.

That aside, the South Africans were probably the best touring side in the country since the 2005 Aussies. The 1-0 scoreline may have flattered us, but still, both the draws were hard fought against a far superior opponent; it's a reasonable achievement in what was a very watchable series, though I felt NZ made things more difficult for themselves with some duff selections (Nicol, Arnel). My feeling is before it can think about winning consistently, the test side needs to learn how to stop losing. This series was a step in that direction.